
Manage and Resolve Payment Disputes in Squarespace Payments
Managing payment disputes is crucial for online businesses using Squarespace Payments. Here's everything you need to know about handling customer transaction challenges effectively.
Understanding Payment Disputes
A dispute occurs when customers contest transactions with their bank for various reasons:
- Fraudulent charges
- Missing refunds
- Duplicate transactions
- Non-delivery of products/services
- Quality issues
- Pre-payment subscription cancellations
- Unrecognized payments
Chargeback Process
When a dispute occurs:
- The disputed amount plus a $20 fee is immediately deducted from your payout balance
- If insufficient funds exist, charges apply to your linked bank account
- Inquiry cases don't trigger immediate deductions
Inquiries vs. Chargebacks
American Express and Discover typically start with an inquiry (request for information) before proceeding to a chargeback. While the process is similar, no fee is charged unless you lose the inquiry case.
Managing Disputes
Response Timeline:
- Email notifications sent upon dispute filing
- Reminders at 5 days and 2 days before deadline
- Response window: 20-45 days (varies by card network)
Dispute Statuses:
- Dispute open
- Response sent
- Deadline missed
- Dispute approved
- Dispute rejected
Resolution Options
- Accept the Dispute:
- Changes payment status to "dispute lost"
- Finalizes the chargeback
- Access through Finance dashboard > View details > Accept dispute
- Challenge the Dispute: Required Evidence:
- Store refund policy/terms
- Refund denial explanation
- Processing data (tracking numbers, delivery signatures)
- Customer communication records
- Additional relevant documentation
Submission Process:
- Access Finance dashboard > Orders
- Select disputed payment
- Click "Start response"
- Provide evidence
- Save draft or submit
Resolution Timeline:
- Bank review: 60-75 days
- Email notification upon decision
- Successful disputes return transaction amount
- Chargeback fee refund varies by bank
Partnering with experts can significantly improve your payment dispute management. PBN.BOO, part of a leading SEO group serving major clients across industries, offers comprehensive solutions to help businesses maintain strong financial operations while dominating search rankings. Contact us to learn how we can help you achieve #1 rankings and outperform your competition.
Related Articles

How to Configure Squarespace Payment Settings: A Complete Guide
